Dog training is essential to your dog’s health. He must learn how to be social and to listen to you to avoid danger. You can use a special type of collar to help you train your dog. To choose the best dog training collar, however, you need to know a few things. It isn’t quite as simple as it looks.
I am here to teach you about training collars and to give you some suggestions about the best dog training collars that you can buy.
First, I will give you some information about training collars and then I will offer up 5 products that could suit your needs.
** Below, you'll find our more detailed reviews, but you can click links above to see the current prices or read customer's reviews on Amazon.
Assess Your Needs And Values
The best dog training collar for you depends on your values and needs. Mellow dogs might only need a collar while dogs with more energy need a harness. Sometimes, however, you need something with a little more function to help you train your dog.
Shock collars are controversial and use an electric charge to deliver a message to your dog from a distance. Choke collars certainly have an unfortunate name. However, unruly dogs who aren’t properly socialized need firm but gentle control. Some collars even use different tones to alert your dog.
Today, shock collars are often called training collars or e-collars because that sounds less frightening to owners. Choke collars are also rebranded as pinch or prong collars. I urge you to set aside your biases for a moment and read more about these types of training collars.
Let’s take a closer look at these two types of collars to get you closer to the best dog training collar for you.
What Is A Shock Collar or An Electric Collar
A shock collar or electric collar uses an electronic signal to deliver a negative stimulus to a dog in training.
Electronic collars are also sometimes called remote trainers. This is their true purpose. They are not supposed to hurt, frighten, or injure your dog in any way. If they do, you aren’t using them correctly.
I want to caution you to take your dog’s size into consideration when using training collars. Obviously, small dogs need less intense correction than large breeds. That is not to say that small dogs can’t be an aggressive handful, however! I’m sure we’ve all met a few tiny, unpleasant pups in our day.
Many dog people are opposed to the use of shock collars. They believe that shock collars pose the following risks:
- They damage the owner/dog bond.
- Dogs feel pain from these collars.
- Electronic collars are animal abuse.
- They’re negative reinforcement.
- People also believe that dogs will lose their personality or have their spirit broken by electronic collars.
Let me address each of these concerns briefly before we move on.
Damaging The Bond Between Dogs and Owners
Owners can use electronic collars to train their dog as a part of a comprehensive training routine without scaring the dog. You will establish a bond with your dog through playing together, sharing mealtimes, general companionship, and also training.
Training is actually a part of bonding with your dog.
The best practice when using an electric collar for dog training is to use the lowest possible effective setting.Your goal is to distract your dog, not hurt or harm him.
A gentle pulse of energy can really help a dog to refocus on you instead of a squirrel or another dog, for instance. In a dangerous situation, a low-level shock can call your dog to attention and give you the time you need to separate him from another dog or keep him from running into a dangerous area.
The point of training collars is to use the least amount of force possible.
Because shock collars aren’t painful or dangerous when used correctly, they are not animal abuse. Although it is possible to use a shock collar as a form of animal abuse, it is not a given.
Your dog actually wants to believe that you are the boss. This is the best thing for your dog and can help both aggressive and anxious dogs as well. You can safely use a training collar to gently show your dog that you are in control of them and the situation at hand, too.
Shock collars are actually not negative reinforcement. Negative reinforcement would be yelling at your dog or taking something away from him. Electronic collars simply distract and refocus your dog, also prompting him to listen to you.
Because you are using a shock collar effectively to train your dog, you will not break his or her spirit. You can use a training collar that is electronic to teach your dog how to behave, and he will still be his normal, playful, friendly self.
I think one of the golden rules of effective dog training is to keep your patience and not punish your dog in anger. If you do this, you risk harming your dog psychologically whether you use a training collar or not.
What Is a Choke Chain or Prong Collar
Believe it or not, prong collars are actually more controversial than shock collars. There is a good reason for this, and you must make up your own mind about what is the best dog training collar for you.
Some experts strongly believe that prong collars do serious damage to a dog’s neck. Your dog may feel pain whenever the collar is on. They look pretty scary and some of the traditional choke collars have sharp prongs that will dig into a dog’s neck.
That being said, many of the new pinch collars have rubber coatings on the prongs or a rounded shape at the ends that are less damaging to dogs.
Conversely, many trainers and animal shelters do use prong collars as a part of a humane training regime.
At the very least, you must take care to fit the choke chain to your dog specifically. Never pull on the chain with great force.
In the video below, you can see one way to use a prong collar effectively. Whether you are comfortable with this or not, however, is entirely up to you.
A Few Tips For Training Your Dog With Training Collars
My folks have a rambunctious dog who is still mostly a puppy. They use a shock collar to train him and it has gone very well. He has certainly received a gentle shock or two, but he quickly learned to respond to the warning tone and never need an actual shock.
They use their training collar to call him back to the house when he wanders too far into the field across the street. They live in a rural area and have used this method to keep Teddy close to home without hurting him.
It has also helped them teach him to leave the poor geese alone that flock nearby.
Follow the Rules:
- Don’t set the collar so high that your dog cries out in pain when he is shocked. You want your dog to respond with a small twinge or shake of his head, not a yelp.
- If you ever have to correct your dog while he is in water, lower the setting on the collar first! Remember that water conducts electricity. Therefore, the same shock might hurt your dog if he is in water.
- You can’t only rely on the collar. Teach your dog obedience in other ways so he understands first that he is supposed to listen to you. The collar only reinforces your control.
- You should always end every training session on a positive note. Ask your dog to perform a task he is comfortable with and reward him with praise and a pat. It is helpful to start off training sessions this way, as well.
- Also, you must remove any other metal collars that your dog is wearing before using a shock collar of any kind. Metal also conducts electricity, of course, and safety is key.
- Occasionally, put the collar on your dog and let him wear it without shocking him. If you do this, your dog will be comfortable with the collar and not necessarily associate it with a bad experience.
- That being said, you can use the collar to send a signal to your dog that it is training time. To do this, only put it on before you begin giving your dog instructions and remove it when you are finished training.
How To Choose The Best Dog Training Collar
First, you must reflect on how you feel about the two controversial styles of training collars I’ve mentioned here. If you feel bad about either of these choices, you should try out a regular buckle collar and some obedience classes with your dog first.
If you feel comfortable trying a shock or choke collar, I will show you a few styles that could be appropriate for your dog. Each of these dog training collars is high-quality and suitable for beginners to learn with.
Please remember to seek help from a professional trainer or your vet if you have any questions. The most important thing is for your dog to always be safe in your hands.
5 Best Dog Training Collars
1. Remote-Controlled Dog Shock Collar
The PetTech shock collar is one of the best dog training collars available. It has many features and several settings to suit your needs.
Additionally, it has a great warranty that is valuable to customers. Therefore, you can use this collar with confidence and know that you can return it if you feel it isn’t up to par. This kind of security is worth paying attention to. This is especially true because a product like a dog collar will get lots of normal wear and tear.
2. Slicemall 500 Yards Rechargeable and Waterproof Remote
This waterproof device will help train your dog that loves water. It also has many settings and is easy to use. Owners can use this collar to stop their dogs from barking.
Additionally, the collar is adjustable and should fit any size dog.
3. Slicemall Rechargeable Dog Training Collar
This collar is similar to the one above. Conversely, this model is not waterproof. This may be fine, however, if you don’t plan on taking your dog to places where he might get wet during training.
This collar is bulkier and not as well suited for the elements. Because of this, the best way to use this collar is occasionally at parks or in obedience training.
4. Bark Solution ® Rechargeable and Rainproof 330 yd
This collar is attractive and easy to use. It is perfect for training your dog at home. There are many adjustable levels of correction that you can use on your dog.
The company invites customers to reach out to them by email if they aren’t satisfied with this product. It is always nice to know that a company values its customers and wants them to have a great experience!
This collar shouldn’t get submerged in water, but it will stand up to rain and tough play, according to the company that manufactures it.
5. Herm. Sprenger® Ultra-Plus Prong Training Collar
This collar has a high-quality German construction that should last for a long time. It is also a good value. You can use it to safely train your dog if you're careful.
That being said, please remember my cautions against misuse of prong or choke collars. Please read all about trainers that use these collars effectively and follow their advice. I also recommend that you speak with your vet about their thoughts regarding prong collars, as well.
My Top Pick- The Best Dog Training Collar
Are you ready for my winning pick? It was a hard choice to make!
I believe the Slicemall 500 Yards Rechargeable and Waterproof Remote Electric Dog Training Collar is the best dog training collar in this review roundup. I like all of its features and it seems durable and easy to operate, as well.
So we know this is a good collar for owners, but what about dogs? We already learned that a shock collar gets a bad rap. It can be perfectly safe to use one on your dog.
Because this brand has so many levels of the impulse to send to your dog, it is easy to pick the intensity level. You don’t even have to shock your dog at all to train them with this collar.
As soon as you successfully socialize your dog, you can stop using e-collars if you want to. Conversely, you can use this collar in any weather condition anytime you walk your dog.
Socialization is healthy for dogs because they get more out of life that way. It also makes it easier for someone else to care for your dog if you go on a trip or need to find a new home for your dog.
Please keep all of the comments respectful so we can foster an open exchange of ideas. We may not all agree on everything all of the time. We love our pets, however. All of us share that common ground.
Thanks for reading and please remember to share this review roundup with any of your dog loving friends.
Because I am here working for you, let me know if there are any subjects you’d like to know more about that relate to your dog. I love learning new things and helping you to do the same. We can learn so much together and build a better world for our lovable furry friends.